Shopping for McFarlane Figures
When the first McFarlane sports figures hit the market I was immediately attracted to them. The quality of the pieces were far more advanced than the Kenner SLU figures. But still with a bit of a bitter taste in my mouth from the demise of the Kenner SLU’s I never really actively collected the McFarlanes. I did speculate on them when the variations were hot and you could triple your money or more pretty easy.
That too, soon ended as one of the problems that plagued the SLU market continued with the McFarlanes. The practice of people getting the variants from the big box stores before they ever hit the shelves. It became very difficult to get the variations unless you knew someone that worked at the store. The end of the line for me in even trying to find variants was one day at lunch when I made one of my weekly visits to a local Game Stop. I was sometimes able to get either a variant or a piece I wanted there and they often marked the old series down when the new series was released. On this particular day I was approached by a new employee there that asked me if I collected McFarlanes. I told him yes, and the players that I liked. He began to explain to me how he had already bought the good pieces and had them in the back. He said he would make me a good deal, I handed him the two pieces I had picked off the shelf and turned and walked out never to return to Game Stop.
It was several months before I bought another McFarlane and now I only buy pieces I really want or ones that are marked down. The last regular priced piece I bought was the Earl Campbell piece. The other day I was in Toys R Us and just like I do every time I am in there I checked out the McFarlane pieces. They had a fresh shipment in and had several Michael Young figures. I wanted one but I refuse to pay $10.99 for it. I am sure if I wait long enough I can get one for under $5. While browsing the figures I found a Robinson Cano Series 17 marked down to $3.98. Just the right price for me, now if they had only had the Beckett for $3.98 it would have been a great haul.
I have a buddy that calls me a cheapskate but I just remind him of all those Kenner SLU’s that aren’t worth anything. What are your thoughts on the McFarlane Sports Figures? If you buy them is it for investment or enjoyment? What is the most you have ever paid for one? For me it was the Campbell for $10.99. What is the most you have ever sold one for? I sold a Jean-Sebastien Giguere for $40 once. By the way, Goalie figures are awesome.


May 28th, 2008 at 7:34 am
I buy my McFarlane figures to open and display. Over to my right I’ve got Paul Pierce, Larry Bird, Bill Russell and Kevin Garnett with the very cool basketball hoop that McFarlane Toys produced. Behind me, I’ve got Big Papi and Papelbon. In my giant Ikea bookcase I’ve got one cube with Tom Brady, Adam Vinatieri and Corey Dillon (still need to track down the Bruschi figure). Another cube has all of the Piazza figures that have been produced along with all of my other Piazza figures. Another cube has a different Big Papi, Varitek (Collector’s Club exclusive), Beckett and Schilling. On top of the bookcase you’ll find Jason Varitek (batting) and Carlton Fisk.
I don’t mind paying the retail price for these, but the big problem in the Boston area is finding the local players at the actual retail price. What I’ll usually do is wait until there are 2 or 3 that I want and then order them from Toys R Us.com to get free shipping.
May 28th, 2008 at 12:39 pm
I too really like the McFarlane Figures. Unlike Mike I only have the one!! Mike’s collection sounds fab though! My figure is of Derek Lee of the Cub’s, looks great in my room. I will hopefully get the Kevin Youkilis, in McFarlane series 20; as well as the Joe Mauer in series 21. The Mauer is of him in his catchers gear, knelt down behind the plate!
With me I just purchase the figures of players I like, and figures I like the look of. No invest with me!
May 28th, 2008 at 1:47 pm
Another figure deboxer here. I only buy the players that I really, really like. I don’t see them as an investment, just a cute desk display item. I have the Series 19 Scott Kazmir and the Series 3 Curt Schilling on my desk at home (next to a few Hello Kitty figurines) and the 3″ Curt Schilling on my desk at work (next to…another Hello Kitty.)
There also seems to be an active segment of the hobby who like to modify their figures somehow by repainting, etc. Some of the work I’ve seen with these (at least via pictures) is absolutely amazing.
May 28th, 2008 at 8:32 pm
Mike,
Sounds like you have a great display. I have some of my figures unboxed too. Good idea on the free shipping at Toys R Us.
Phil,
I might have to get that Mauer figure too. You can never go wrong buying what you like.
Nicole,
I don’t think I ever saw the Kazmir at retail in my area. I have been tempted to try a custom figure myself. Adam over at the Sportslizard has all the instructions and great photos of examples.
Thanks for the input everyone.
May 28th, 2008 at 11:58 pm
I have a little pile of Kenners still in the boxes. Mostly Braves, some hockey and a couple of football. I never really saw them as an investment, but just something fun to collect. I never really got into the McFarlanes though, but when I saw Hank Aaron in the 1974 uniform I had to get it.
May 29th, 2008 at 5:36 am
Hey Dayf, that Aaron is a good looking piece. Thanks for chiming in.
May 29th, 2008 at 6:55 am
Hi Joey, the last McFarlane figure I bought (on ebay) was Chien-Ming Wang, it cost me $15. I don’t really collect them because the shipping charge to The UK is too much (around $10)
My local comic shop (in Glasgow, Scotland) have many of the old legend series on sale for £3/ $6. I managed to get a Babe Ruth sepia variant and cal ripken jr for just $12 total what a deal!. I think the comic shop owner found out that not many people follow baseball in Scotland.
We haven’t had any new baseball figures since, mainly hockey only.
May 29th, 2008 at 8:19 pm
Graham,
Wow, a collector in Scotland. I love to hear from folks in far away places that collect cards and stuff. Nice grabs on the Ruth and Ripken.
I hope to hear from you again.
May 30th, 2008 at 6:06 am
Hi Graham, nice to see another UK baseball fan!! The Chien Ming-Wang figure you mention is a nice looking piece, but like you I don’t have many due to the high shipping prices!!